Auto coverage that doesn't punish you for an honest commute.
Tell us your ZIP, vehicle and a few basics. We line up estimated premiums and customer-satisfaction scores from eight major US carriers, side by side, so you can see the trade-offs before you ever pick up the phone. Liability, collision, comprehensive — same coverage tier on every row.
Eight auto carriers, same fields every row.
Estimated monthly premiums for a 35-year-old driver with a clean record and full coverage. Final number moves with ZIP, vehicle, history and credit-based insurance score.
| Carrier | Score | Est. monthly | Est. yearly | Satisfaction | Coverage area | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Progressive
Best name-your-price tool
|
4.7 | $62 / mo | $744 / yr | 672 / 1,000 | All 50 states | View → |
|
Geico
Best low rate
|
4.6 | $58 / mo | $696 / yr | 678 / 1,000 | All 50 states | View → |
|
State Farm
Best agent network
|
4.5 | $68 / mo | $816 / yr | 692 / 1,000 | All 50 states | View → |
|
USAA
Military only
|
4.9 | $52 / mo | $624 / yr | 875 / 1,000 | Military families | View → |
|
Allstate
Best for accident forgiveness
|
4.4 | $89 / mo | $1,068 / yr | 668 / 1,000 | All 50 states | View → |
|
Liberty Mutual
Best customizable coverage
|
4.3 | $86 / mo | $1,032 / yr | 660 / 1,000 | All 50 states | View → |
|
Nationwide
Best for SmartMiles
|
4.4 | $73 / mo | $876 / yr | 672 / 1,000 | 47 states | View → |
|
Farmers
Best signal app discounts
|
4.4 | $79 / mo | $948 / yr | 660 / 1,000 | All 50 states | View → |
Estimates only. Final premium is set by the carrier based on your driving record, vehicle, ZIP, credit-based insurance score and selected coverage. USAA is restricted to active-duty military, veterans and their immediate family. Cankicker Finance is a comparison platform — we are not an insurance carrier and do not write policies. Some carriers compensate us when you click through — see our Advertising Disclosure.
How auto insurance pricing actually works.
Three things that explain almost every "why is my quote so different from my neighbor's?" question.
The 30-factor rating model
Carriers blend roughly thirty inputs to set your premium — ZIP-level claim frequency, vehicle theft data, your credit-based insurance score (in the 47 states that allow it), prior carrier history, annual mileage, even garaging address. Two drivers with matching ages, cars and clean records can land $30/mo apart simply because one lives on the wrong side of a ZIP boundary or carried a six-month lapse three years ago. The model isn't punishing you personally; it's pricing the statistical bucket you sit in.
Liability is the line that matters
"25/50/25" means $25,000 per person for bodily injury, $50,000 per accident, $25,000 for property damage. That is the legal floor in most states — and it covers roughly one ER visit and one totaled SUV before you're personally on the hook. If your liability runs out, the other driver's attorney comes after your wages, savings and home equity. Stepping up from 25/50/25 to 100/300/100 typically adds $8 to $14 a month and buys you four times the protection.
Deductibles vs. premiums
Raising a $500 collision deductible to $1,000 typically drops a comprehensive premium 10 to 15 percent. Going from $1,000 to $2,500 drops it another 8 to 12 percent. The math only works if you can actually cover the deductible from cash on hand on the day of a claim — and if the annual premium savings beat the additional risk you carry yourself. Bigger deductible equals lower premium equals more skin in the game.
Where auto-insurance shoppers usually leave money on the table.
What state minimums actually buy you (and why most experts say 100/300/100 is the new floor)
Every state sets a legal minimum for auto liability and most of those floors haven't been meaningfully raised in twenty years. Florida's minimum is 10/20/10. California sits at 15/30/5. Even relatively generous states like New York cap their minimum bodily-injury at 25/50. The problem is that one ambulance transport plus an overnight in a hospital can run $40,000, and a totaled crossover can clear $35,000. If your liability limit runs out at the scene, the other driver's attorney pursues your wages, your savings, and any home equity you've built. Carrying state-minimum coverage to save fifteen dollars a month is the financial equivalent of leaving the front door unlocked because deadbolts feel inconvenient. For any driver with a stable income or a mortgage, 100/300/100 is the modern floor — and 250/500/250 is the right call if you own a home outright. The premium step-up is small. The protection step-up is large.
Liability vs. comprehensive vs. collision: when to drop each
Liability is required by law in every state except New Hampshire, and you should never drop it — that's the part that protects everyone outside your own vehicle. Collision and comprehensive are different. Collision pays for damage to your own car after an accident; comprehensive pays for theft, weather, falling objects and animal strikes. Both become economically marginal once your car ages out. The rule of thumb most independent advisors use: when your annual comp-and-collision premium exceeds about ten percent of your car's actual cash value, the math starts breaking down. A twelve-year-old commuter worth $4,000 carrying $600 a year in comp-and-collision is a candidate to drop. A three-year-old SUV worth $28,000 is not. Run the number against your own savings buffer — if you couldn't replace the car out of pocket, keep the coverage regardless.
How your driving record actually affects your rate (3-year vs. 5-year lookback)
Most carriers use a three-year lookback for moving violations and a five-year lookback for at-fault accidents and DUIs, but the windows vary by state and by carrier. A single speeding ticket in the 11-to-15-mph-over band typically adds 15 to 25 percent to your premium for three years before rolling off. A single at-fault accident adds 30 to 50 percent for five years. A DUI roughly doubles the premium and stays on the books for five to ten years depending on the state. Two practical implications: first, the cheapest time to shop for a new carrier is right after a violation rolls off your record, because the new carrier rates you without it. Second, "accident forgiveness" riders — Allstate is best-known for them — are worth their cost only if you actually file a claim during the policy period. Otherwise, you've paid for a feature you never used.
Why bundling auto + home isn't always the cheapest option
Bundling discounts get pitched as a no-brainer — fifteen to twenty-five percent off both policies, why wouldn't you? — but the savings often disappear when you compare a bundle to two best-in-class standalone policies. Here's the math. Suppose Carrier A bundles your auto and home for $2,400 a year combined, after a 20 percent discount. Without bundling, Carrier A's auto-only quote might be $1,400 and the home-only quote $1,700, totaling $3,100 — so the bundle saves $700. But if Carrier B prices your auto at $900 and Carrier C prices your home at $1,200, you're at $2,100 unbundled across two carriers. The bundle costs you $300 more, not less. Always pull standalone quotes alongside the bundle, set every quote to the same coverage tier, and let the total cost decide. We are not an insurance carrier — but our comparison view shows both views so the trade-off is visible up front.
Estimates only. Final terms set by the carrier. This editorial reflects independent analysis from the Cankicker Finance team. We are not an insurance carrier and do not write policies. We may earn a referral fee from carriers mentioned — see our Advertising Disclosure.
Common questions about auto insurance
Will getting auto-insurance quotes hurt my credit?
Will a parking ticket affect my auto insurance rate?
How long does an at-fault accident stay on my record?
Should I take the full-coverage option if my car is paid off?
What's the difference between gap insurance and full coverage?
Save quotes in the app, revisit before renewal
Pin your top three carriers, get a nudge thirty days before your policy renews, and re-run the comparison in 60 seconds. Free in the App Store.