Auto
Liability, collision and comprehensive quotes from the eight largest US carriers in our network.
Compare auto →Tell us your ZIP and a few basics. We'll line up estimated premiums and customer-satisfaction scores from our partner carriers, side by side, so you can see the trade-offs before you ever pick up the phone.
Auto is where most people start — but the same side-by-side view works for everything below.
Liability, collision and comprehensive quotes from the eight largest US carriers in our network.
Compare auto →Dwelling, contents and liability coverage compared by ZIP, replacement cost and deductible tier.
Compare home →The cheapest line of defense most renters skip — usually around $15/mo for $30,000 of coverage.
Compare renters →Accident-and-illness plans for dogs and cats — read the pre-existing condition exclusions before you buy.
Compare pet →Marketplace and direct-to-consumer plans where they're available. Subsidies depend on your state and income.
Compare health →Estimated premiums for a 35-year-old driver with a clean record and full coverage. Your number will move with ZIP, vehicle, history and credit-based insurance score.
| Carrier | Rating | Est. monthly | Est. yearly | Satisfaction | Coverage area | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Progressive
Best name-your-price
|
4.7 | $62 / mo | $744 / yr | 672 / 1,000 | All 50 states | View → |
|
Geico
Best low rate
|
4.6 | $58 / mo | $696 / yr | 678 / 1,000 | All 50 states | View → |
|
State Farm
Best agent network
|
4.5 | $68 / mo | $816 / yr | 692 / 1,000 | All 50 states | View → |
|
USAA
Military families only
|
4.9 | $52 / mo | $624 / yr | 875 / 1,000 | Military families | View → |
|
Allstate
Best for accident forgiveness
|
4.4 | $89 / mo | $1,068 / yr | 668 / 1,000 | All 50 states | View → |
|
Liberty Mutual
|
4.3 | $86 / mo | $1,032 / yr | 662 / 1,000 | All 50 states | View → |
|
Nationwide
|
4.4 | $73 / mo | $876 / yr | 684 / 1,000 | 47 states | View → |
|
Farmers
|
4.2 | $79 / mo | $948 / yr | 670 / 1,000 | All 50 states | View → |
Estimates only. Final premiums are determined by the carrier based on your driving record, vehicle, ZIP, credit-based insurance score and selected coverage. USAA is restricted to active-duty military, veterans and their immediate family. Cankicker Finance is a comparison platform — we are not an insurance carrier and do not write policies. Some carriers compensate us for clicks; see Advertising Disclosure.
Three things that explain almost every "why is my quote so different from my neighbor's?" question.
Carriers use 30+ rating factors — ZIP-level claim frequency, vehicle theft data, your credit-based insurance score, prior carrier history, even mileage. Two drivers with matching ages, cars and clean records can land $30/mo apart simply because one lives on the wrong side of a ZIP boundary or carried a lapse three years ago. The model isn't punishing you personally; it's pricing the statistical bucket you sit in.
A "25/50/25" policy means $25,000 per person for bodily injury, $50,000 per accident, and $25,000 for property damage. That is the legal floor in many states — and it covers roughly one trip to the ER and one totaled SUV before you're personally on the hook. Most independent advisors recommend at least 100/300/100 if you have any assets, savings or future earnings to protect.
Raising a $500 deductible to $1,000 typically drops a comprehensive premium 10–15%. Going from $1,000 to $2,500 drops it another 8–12%. The math only works if you can actually cover the deductible from cash on hand on the day of a claim — and if your savings rate makes the annual premium difference worth it. Bigger deductible = lower premium = more risk you carry yourself.
Coverage minimums, deductible tradeoffs, and the renters-and-pet plans most people skip until it's too late.
Every state sets a legal minimum for auto liability — and in most states that minimum is dangerously low. Florida's floor is 10/20/10. California sits at 15/30/5. Even relatively generous states like New York cap their minimum bodily-injury at 25/50. The problem is that one ambulance ride plus one overnight in a hospital can run $40,000, and a totaled crossover can run $35,000. If your liability runs out, the other driver's attorney comes after your wages, your savings, and any equity you've built. Carrying state-minimum coverage to save $15 a month is the financial equivalent of leaving your front door unlocked because deadbolts are inconvenient. We'd recommend 100/300/100 at minimum for any driver with a stable income, and 250/500/250 if you own a home outright.
Carriers price each policy as a stack of independent risk pools, and the comprehensive-and-collision portion is the most deductible-sensitive piece. A typical full-coverage quote in our network shifts roughly 18–22% if you move a $500 deductible to $1,500. That is real money — about $180 a year on the median Progressive or Geico quote — and the breakeven math is straightforward. If you go five years without a comprehensive claim (which most drivers do), you've banked nine hundred dollars and given up nothing. The catch: you have to actually keep that money set aside. The deductible only "saves" you if you can write the check on the day of the claim without putting it on a 24% credit card. We are not an insurance carrier, but our comparison view shows quote shifts at three deductible tiers so the tradeoff is visible up front.
Roughly half of American renters skip renters insurance, usually because they assume their landlord's policy covers them. It does not. A landlord's policy covers the building; your stuff, your liability, and your living expenses if the unit becomes uninhabitable are entirely on you. Lemonade, the cheapest carrier in our partner network, prices a typical renters policy at around $15/month for $30,000 of personal property and $100,000 of liability. That is less than a single streaming service, and it covers theft, fire, water damage from a burst pipe, and lawsuits if your dog bites a guest. If you rent and don't carry it, you're effectively self-insuring your laptop, your bike, your mattress, and a six-figure liability gap — to save the price of two coffees a week.
Pet insurance can absolutely make sense — a single ACL tear or foreign-body surgery can run $4,000–$8,000 — but every plan in the US excludes pre-existing conditions, and the carriers' definition of "pre-existing" is broader than most owners realize. If your dog was seen for a limp last year, anything orthopedic on that leg may be excluded for life. If your cat was treated for a UTI, urinary issues going forward can be excluded. The right time to enroll is when the animal is young and has no clinical history. Healthy Paws, Embrace and Trupanion all offer 30-day waiting periods and lifetime coverage thresholds; the differences are in deductible structure, payout caps, and whether they cover exam fees. Compare on those three axes, not just monthly premium.
The single biggest mistake shoppers make is comparing premiums without normalizing the underlying policy. Carrier A's $58/mo quote may carry 25/50/25 limits and a $1,000 deductible; Carrier B's $73/mo quote may include 100/300/100, a $500 deductible, roadside assistance, and rental reimbursement. The second policy isn't more expensive — it's more policy. When you run a comparison on Cankicker Finance, every carrier is shown at the same coverage tier you select, with deductibles aligned and optional riders priced separately. That's the only way the monthly number means anything. Pull at least three quotes, set them all to the same coverage and deductible, and pick on satisfaction score and claim-handling reputation rather than the lowest sticker.
Pin your top three carriers, get a nudge 30 days before your policy renews, and re-run the comparison in 60 seconds. Free in the App Store.