Free comparison platform · Pueblo, Colorado
Home insurance

Homeowners cover priced for the house you actually own.

Tell us your ZIP, square footage and roof age. We line up estimated annual premiums and customer-satisfaction scores from eight homeowners carriers — including digital-first Lemonade and the regional incumbents — at the same coverage tier on every row.

Privacy secured · Advertising disclosure
$1,687
Average annual homeowners premium in the US for 2025 (NAIC) — your number depends on ZIP, build year and dwelling value
80%
Replacement-cost coverage rule — drop below this and your claims get pro-rated, not paid in full
0%
Of standard policies that cover flood damage — you need a separate NFIP or private flood policy
$0
Cost to compare on Cankicker Finance — referral fees come from carriers, never from you
Side-by-side

Eight homeowners carriers, same fields every row.

Estimated annual premiums for a typical $400k single-family home with $1,000 deductible and replacement-cost coverage. Final number moves with ZIP, dwelling value, roof age and claim history.

Carrier Score Est. yearly Est. monthly Satisfaction Coverage area
State Farm
Best overall
4.7 $1,500 / yr $125 / mo 802 / 1,000 All 50 states View →
Lemonade
Best digital-first
4.7 $1,100 / yr $92 / mo 836 / 1,000 23 states View →
Allstate
Best discounts
4.5 $1,650 / yr $138 / mo 781 / 1,000 All 50 states View →
Nationwide
Best for new builds
4.5 $1,580 / yr $132 / mo 800 / 1,000 47 states View →
USAA
Military only
4.9 $1,200 / yr $100 / mo 882 / 1,000 Military families View →
Liberty Mutual
Best customizable
4.4 $1,700 / yr $142 / mo 772 / 1,000 All 50 states View →
Farmers
Best wildfire markets
4.4 $1,750 / yr $146 / mo 776 / 1,000 All 50 states View →
Travelers Best high-value homes 4.5 $1,800 / yr $150 / mo 790 / 1,000 All 50 states View →

Estimates only. Final premium is set by the carrier based on dwelling value, ZIP, roof age, claim history and selected coverage. USAA is restricted to active-duty military, veterans and their immediate family. Lemonade is currently available in 23 states. Cankicker Finance is a comparison platform — we are not an insurance carrier. Some carriers compensate us when you click through — see our Advertising Disclosure.

How it works

How home insurance pricing actually works.

Three things every homeowner should understand before clicking buy.

01

Coverage A is the spine of the policy

Every homeowners policy is built on Coverage A — the dwelling limit. That's the dollar amount the carrier will pay to rebuild your house from the foundation up after a total loss. It is not the same as your home's market value or your purchase price. Carriers calculate Coverage A from rebuild cost: square footage, finish quality, regional construction labor and material costs. In a hot housing market, it's common for Coverage A to sit thirty percent below sale price — that's normal, because rebuilds don't include the land.

02

Standard policies don't cover everything

The standard HO-3 policy in the US covers fire, wind, hail, theft, vandalism and most water damage from inside the home. It does not cover flood (need NFIP or private flood), earthquake (separate rider, mandatory in California), sewer backup (cheap rider, often $50/year) or, increasingly in coastal markets, named-storm wind (separate hurricane deductible). Read the declarations page for the exclusions section before you sign — that's the page that tells you what isn't covered, not the marketing brochure.

03

Deductibles work differently here

Home insurance deductibles often have two tiers: a flat dollar amount for most claims ($1,000 typical) and a percentage-based deductible for hurricane, wind or named-storm claims (1 to 5 percent of dwelling value). On a $400k home with a 2 percent wind deductible, you're paying the first $8,000 out of pocket on a hurricane claim — not $1,000. Check the wind/hurricane line item every renewal, because carriers in coastal states have been steadily raising it.

The home-insurance details that decide whether a claim actually pays.

Replacement cost vs. actual cash value (the difference matters)

This is the single most important line item on a homeowners policy and almost no one reads it. Replacement cost (RCV) coverage pays what it would cost today to rebuild your home or replace the contents with equivalent quality, no depreciation deducted. Actual cash value (ACV) coverage pays the depreciated value — what your eight-year-old roof is worth today, not what a new roof costs. The difference is real money. A $20,000 roof replacement claim under RCV pays $20,000. The same claim under ACV, with an eight-year-old composition roof, might pay $7,000, leaving you to cover $13,000 yourself. Most policies default to RCV on the dwelling and ACV on the roof — that ACV roof endorsement has quietly become standard in storm-heavy states because it lets carriers offer a lower headline premium. Read the declarations page. If your roof is more than fifteen years old, ACV may be the only option a carrier will offer; budget the difference into your roofing fund instead of assuming the policy will cover it.

Hurricane / flood / earthquake: when standard policy doesn't cover you

Three perils that many homeowners assume are covered, and aren't. Flood is excluded from every standard homeowners policy in the United States — full stop. If you're in a FEMA-designated flood zone, your mortgage requires NFIP coverage, but anyone outside a flood zone has to buy it voluntarily, and roughly twenty-five percent of NFIP claims come from outside high-risk zones. Earthquake is excluded everywhere except as a paid rider; in California it's a separate CEA policy, typically $800 to $2,000 a year. Hurricane wind is technically covered, but most coastal states now use a separate percentage-based deductible (1 to 5 percent of dwelling value) that kicks in when a storm is officially named. The honest move: pull your policy declarations once a year, look at the perils-excluded section, and price out riders for any peril your ZIP actually faces. The math on a $300/year flood policy versus a $40,000 flood claim is not subtle.

The 80% rule: why under-insuring kicks back at claim time

Most homeowners policies include a coinsurance clause that requires you to insure your dwelling at no less than eighty percent of its replacement cost. Drop below that threshold and the carrier doesn't simply pay less on a partial loss — they pro-rate every claim by the ratio of your actual coverage to the required eighty percent. Numerical example: rebuild cost on your home is $400,000, so the 80% threshold is $320,000. You carry $240,000 of dwelling coverage to save on premium. A kitchen fire causes $80,000 of damage. The carrier owes you $80,000 × ($240,000 / $320,000) = $60,000, minus your deductible. You're out of pocket $20,000 you didn't expect. The fix is annual: ask your agent or carrier to re-run the rebuild cost estimate every year, particularly after any major remodel. Construction inflation has run roughly seven percent annually for the last four years; a Coverage A figure that was correct in 2022 is probably twenty-five percent low today.

How to inventory your home so a claim actually reimburses you

Personal property coverage typically runs at fifty to seventy percent of your dwelling limit, but actually collecting on it after a total loss requires you to prove what you owned. Most homeowners cannot. After a fire, you have thirty to sixty days to submit a sworn proof of loss listing every claimed item, with purchase year and approximate value. From memory, while standing in temporary housing, that's a brutal exercise. The fix takes ninety minutes once and protects you forever: walk every room with your phone in video mode, narrate what you're filming ("Sony 65-inch TV, bought 2023, paid $1,200"), open closets and cabinets so jewelry, electronics and tools are visible, and back the file up to cloud storage so it survives the very loss it documents. For high-value items — jewelry, art, firearms, collectibles — schedule them as named riders on the policy with appraisals attached. Standard personal property coverage caps jewelry at $1,500 to $2,500 in a single loss; a scheduled rider raises that cap and removes the deductible.

Estimates only. Final terms set by the carrier. This editorial reflects independent analysis from the Cankicker Finance team. We are not an insurance carrier and do not write policies. We may earn a referral fee from carriers mentioned — see our Advertising Disclosure.

Common questions about home insurance

Does standard home insurance cover flooding?
No. Flood damage is excluded from every standard homeowners policy in the United States. If you're in a FEMA-designated flood zone, your mortgage lender will require a separate NFIP (National Flood Insurance Program) policy. Even outside a designated flood zone, flooding accounts for a meaningful share of total home losses — about a quarter of NFIP claims come from low or moderate-risk areas. Pricing is typically $400 to $1,200 a year depending on zone.
How is my home's coverage amount calculated?
Carriers calculate dwelling coverage (Coverage A) based on rebuild cost, not market value or purchase price. Inputs include square footage, finish quality, regional construction labor and material costs, foundation type and any custom features. In hot housing markets, rebuild cost is often well below sale price because the land doesn't burn down. Ask for the rebuild calculation worksheet at renewal — most carriers will share it.
Will filing a claim raise my premium?
Usually yes, especially for water-damage and weather claims. A single non-catastrophic claim typically adds 10 to 30 percent to your premium for the next three to five years. Two claims in a five-year window puts you at risk of non-renewal. The math: if you have a $4,000 claim with a $1,000 deductible, you're collecting $3,000 — but a 20 percent premium increase on a $1,500 annual policy adds $1,500 over five years. For small claims, paying out of pocket often wins.
What's the difference between HO-3 and HO-5?
HO-3 is the standard policy: dwelling is open-perils (everything is covered unless specifically excluded), but personal property is named-perils (only listed perils are covered). HO-5 upgrades both to open-perils — your personal property is covered for any cause of loss not specifically excluded. HO-5 typically costs 10 to 20 percent more than HO-3 and is worth it if you have meaningful contents value or live in a market where claims tend to be complex.
Do I need umbrella insurance on top of homeowners?
If your net worth exceeds your homeowners liability limit (typically $300,000 to $500,000), yes. An umbrella policy adds $1 million to $5 million of liability protection across your home, auto and watercraft policies for roughly $200 to $400 a year. It's the cheapest insurance per dollar of protection on the market, and it kicks in only after the underlying policy limit is exhausted — so for most households, an umbrella will go an entire lifetime without ever paying a claim.

Save quotes in the app, revisit before renewal

Pin your top three carriers, get a nudge thirty days before your policy renews, and re-run the comparison in 60 seconds. Free in the App Store.